Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
More Info
I would like to contribute
- Immigration
- State Budget
- New York
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (2) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (2)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/CACHE/images/politifact/photos/NYC_migrants_in_the_rain/0a0a14c1558225a7d62c1f4cd7288a4c.jpg)
Migrants run in the rain Jan. 9, 2024, at a migrant housing location in New York City. (AP)
By Jill Terreri RamosMay 30, 2024
If Your Time is short
During the next two years, the New York state budget allocates $2.4 billion for support for migrants.
Some of this funding will fund health care, such as immunizations and disease testing, as well as shelter services.
The funding is flexible, and the city can use it on ‘humanitarian aid’ and ‘services and assistance.’
New York taxpayers are spending $2.4 billion on services for migrants in New York City, prompting claims from some lawmakers about what the migrants are receiving.
Assemblymember Doug Smith, a Long Island Republican, shared an image on his social media accounts that claimed the recently enacted state budget includes free health care and debit cards for "illegal immigrants."
The cost of providing services for a surge of migrants has been grabbing headlines, so we wondered if Smith’s statement is correct.
The new budget covers spending from April 1 through March 31, 2025, and allocates$2.4 billion for migrant services over fiscal years 2025 and 2026. The budget doesn’t spell out exactly what the money will be spent on, using broad terms like "humanitarian aid," and "services and assistance." But it also states the money should be used for specific items such as immunizations and communicable disease testing. A city budget document calls this state allocation "flexible funding."
The $2.4 billion allocation is included in the state’s Aid to Localities bill, and it’s "for services and expenses associated with the costs of migrant individuals and families entering New York State pursuant to a plan approved by the director of the budget. Such services and expenses shall include, but not be limited to: aid to New York City for providing humanitarian aid, including short term shelter services for such migrant individuals and families; aid to New York City for case management and legal services for such migrant individuals and families; programs to provide services and assistance to such migrant individuals and families; programs to provide immunizations for and communicable disease testing of such individuals and families; programs to assist in relocation and resettlement."
Funds are also available for any state division or the National Guard.
Gov. Kathy Hochul, when discussing budget highlights in January, said the allocation would go toward helping New York City shelter migrants.
New York City Mayor Eric Adams told the state Legislature in February the money is not enough to cover the city’s growing expenses associated with the new arrivals. In the city’s fiscal year 2025 budget document, released on April 24, the city estimates that more than 190,000 migrants have arrived since July 2022, and that costs associated with them will reach $10 billion by 2025. In Adams’ city budget message, he said the $2.4 billion from the state is "flexible funding" for costs associated with migrants, with $1.06 billion for sheltering migrants, and $637 million for Humanitarian Emergency Response and Relief Centers, or HERRCs, at Creedmoor Psychiatric Center, Randall’s Islandand Floyd Bennett Field.
Lawmakers asked Adams and his budget team in February what the city would spend the money on.
"Some of it is going to be spent already on the Humanitarian Relief Centers that we have in place and it's going to be spent on housing and some of the other needs that come with asylum seekers," Adams said. "We have to, and I think it's important for all of us to know, we have to take the full care of the asylum seekers. That's cleaning, housing, feeding, everything a family needs."
The state financial plan from February offers additional specificity. The state has assisted with state public health insurance programs for people who are eligibleand "safety net assistance" for asylum seekers who are eligible.
It’s unclear whether the "safety net assistance" in the state budget for the city means the money will fund the prepaid debit cards the city is issuing to migrants to purchase food and baby supplies. New York City provided the debit cards because migrants are not eligible for traditional food stamp benefits that are issued on electronic benefit cards.
PolitiFact left questions six times by email and phone with the state Division of Budget over two weeks but received no response. The city’s Division of Management and Budget also did not respond to twoinquiries.
On the claim the money will fund "free health care," various health care and insurance options are available to immigrants in New York City. Eligibility for each program varies. The state’s Child Health Plus plan offers health insurance coverage for all children, regardless of immigration status. All migrants can also get Medicaid for emergency treatment, or traditional Medicaid if they are pregnant. Medicaid is free or very low cost. The city’s public hospitals provide health care to all immigrants regardless of a person’s ability to pay.
Smith, the Long Island Assembly member, sent several news articles about the city’s use of prepaid debit cards and migrant access to health care as evidence for his claim.
The state budget allocation to the city is flexible, and we cannot determine whether it will be used to fund pre-paid debit cards. We will not rate this claim on the Truth-O-Meter.
Immigrant advocates we spoke with also said that coming to the United States to seek asylum or temporary protected status is not illegal, so Smith’s use of the term is misleading.
Our Sources
X post, Assemblyman Doug Smith, @DougSmithNY, April 24, 2024.
Email interview, Assemblymember Doug Smith, May 3, 2024.
Email interview, Reed Dunlea, press secretary, The New York Immigration Coalition, April 30, 2024.
Email interview, Ken Giardin, research director, Empire Center for Public Policy, April 30, 2024.
Email interview, Shaina Coronel, director of communications, New York City Mayor’s Office of Immigrant Affairs, May 2, 2024.
Transcript, testimony of New York City Mayor Eric Adams on New York state executive budget for fiscal year 2025, Senate Finance and Assembly Ways and Means committees, Feb. 6, 2024.
City of New York Executive Budget Fiscal Year 2025, Message of the Mayor, April 24, 2024.
The New York Times, "$2.4 Billion Is Not Enough for New York’s Migrant Crisis, Adams Says," Feb. 6, 2024.
New York State, news release, "Video, Audio, Photos & Rush Transcript: Governor Hochul Announces Highlights of FY 2025 Budget," Jan. 16, 2024.
New York State Fiscal Year 2025 Aid to Localities Budget Bill, Senate Bill S8303D, Pages 709-710.
New York State Fiscal Year 2025 Executive Budget Financial Plan, Updated for Governor’s Amendments and Forecast Revisions, February 2024.
Transcript, New York Mayor Eric Adams Holds In-Person Media Availability, March 26, 2024.
PolitiFact, "Hochul’s defense of migrants’ presence in New York state has legal basis, experts say," June 20, 2023.
NYC.gov, "Guide to Health Insurance and Health Care Services for Immigrants in New York City," 2016.
NYC.gov Health Insurance Link, Health insurance options for immigrants, undated.
Browse the Truth-O-Meter
More by Jill Terreri Ramos
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (5) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (5)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/CACHE/images/politifact/mugs/Kathy_Hochul_Thumbnail/55ac43101e7356f287bc5c823d7f4e21.jpg)
Kathy Hochul
stated on February 22, 2024 in an interview:
In New York, there are no barriers to law enforcement to work with the federal government on immigration laws, and there are 100 crimes where migrants can be handed over.
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (7) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (7)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/img/meter-barely-true.jpg)
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (9) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (9)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/CACHE/images/politifact/mugs/Stefanik_Thumbnail/29a8f7acd49ed66601192eba90aa018b.jpg)
Elise Stefanik
stated on January 28, 2024 in a television interview:
“We’ve seen an 800% increase in the Swanton sector, which is the part of the northern border that I represent, in illegal crossings.”
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (11) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (11)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/img/meter-true.jpg)
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (13) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (13)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/CACHE/images/politifact/mugs/lalota_mug/ed6cfbe924882ef91d9ff5cd3a9484b7.jpg)
Nick LaLota
stated on November 18, 2023 in a social media post:
Under New York’s Clean Slate Act “violent crimes … will now be automatically sealed after a set time - like they never happened.”
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (15) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (15)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/img/meter-barely-true.jpg)
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (17) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (17)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/CACHE/images/politifact/mugs/NYCAlogo/328ebd91d3422990efdbd1cb03377856.jpg)
New York Citizens Audit
stated on August 25, 2023 in a report:
A discrepancy in the number of ballots and voters in the 2022 general election in New York “appears to be a federal crime.”
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (19) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (19)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/img/meter-false.jpg)
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (21) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (21)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/CACHE/images/politifact/mugs/Nicole_Malliotakis_Thumbnail/fb447b611a27a9191348587316f6db3d.jpg)
Nicole Malliotakis
stated on July 14, 2023 in a radio interview:
“You can work at some McDonald’s in this country for more money than … signing up for the military.”
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (23) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (23)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/img/meter-half-true.jpg)
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (25) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (25)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/CACHE/images/politifact/mugs/AP_21317587955677/27c84ec6611b493fb86b3efcfa1e3ef1.jpg)
Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
stated on June 5, 2023 in a podcast:
Atrazine in the water supply is contributing to "sexual dysphoria" in kids.
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (27) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (27)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/img/meter-false.jpg)
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (29) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (29)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/CACHE/images/politifact/mugs/Kathy_Hochul_Thumbnail/55ac43101e7356f287bc5c823d7f4e21.jpg)
Kathy Hochul
stated on May 9, 2023 in a news conference:
The New York state budget covers 96% of eligible preschoolers
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (31) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (31)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/img/meter-mostly-true.jpg)
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (33) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (33)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/CACHE/images/politifact/mugs/download_11/0367e36ef90ba2d6653597d8486e415c.jpg)
TikTok posts
stated on April 26, 2023 in a TikTok post:
Fauci, DOD and CDC funded deadly pathogen research at Sudan lab
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (35) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (35)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/img/meter-false.jpg)
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (37) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (37)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/CACHE/images/politifact/mugs/Facebook_Logo_2019/caa2aa7d5b5be4d8c1a06fa4f06aff45.jpg)
Facebook posts
stated on March 1, 2023 in a social media post:
New York Gov. Kathy Hochul wants “quarantine camps” and “imprisonment” if you’re suspected of having a disease.
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (39) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (39)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/img/meter-pants-fire.jpg)
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (41) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (41)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/CACHE/images/politifact/mugs/AP_19302682326668/b79640507d1afdeb0fdff8a638e82a02.jpg)
Ron DeSantis
stated on March 20, 2023 in a news conference:
Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg “has downgraded over 50% of the felonies to misdemeanors.”
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (43) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (43)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/img/meter-true.jpg)
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (45) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (45)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/CACHE/images/politifact/mugs/Stefanik_Thumbnail/29a8f7acd49ed66601192eba90aa018b.jpg)
Elise Stefanik
stated on February 9, 2023 in a Tweet:
53% of Americans made aware of the Hunter Biden laptop story would have changed their vote in 2020.
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (47) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (47)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/img/meter-false.jpg)
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (49) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (49)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/CACHE/images/politifact/mugs/Ortt_pic/13973db2230c724e13672ea9a768f26d.jpg)
Robert Ortt
stated on January 20, 2023 in in a news conference:
If New York’s proposed limits on natural gas in buildings take effect, the grid today can’t handle the increased electric load.
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (51) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (51)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/img/meter-true.jpg)
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (53) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (53)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/CACHE/images/politifact/mugs/Adams_Headshot/ad4fe9d3962f6798d3050a988a0bb8ac.jpeg)
Eric Adams
stated on January 7, 2023 in a radio interview:
“Fifty-one percent of our taxes are paid by 2% of New Yorkers.”
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (55) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (55)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/img/meter-mostly-true.jpg)
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (57) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (57)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/CACHE/images/politifact/mugs/Will_Barclay/67ea6241fd96a48aac8bc8f9ed8a39a6.jpeg)
William Barclay
stated on December 1, 2022 in a radio interview:
California has twice the population of New York, but spends $260 billion, while New York spends $220 billion.
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (59) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (59)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/img/meter-barely-true.jpg)
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (61) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (61)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/CACHE/images/politifact/mugs/Facebook_Logo_2019/caa2aa7d5b5be4d8c1a06fa4f06aff45.jpg)
Facebook posts
stated on December 7, 2022 in a post on Facebook:
A $5,000 stimulus loan is available.
![NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (63) NY state funding for migrants can be used on health care and (63)](https://i0.wp.com/static.politifact.com/img/meter-false.jpg)
State budget allocates ‘flexible’ funding for migrant support in New York City
Social Media
stated on May 28, 2024 in social media posts:
"Warner Bros Cancels $10 Million Project Starring 'Woke' Robert De Niro.”
Instagram posts
stated on May 27, 2024 in an Instagram post:
Joe Biden told West Point graduates that “he is not planning to accept the results of the 2024 election” and he wants them to “stand back and stand by” to ensure Donald J. Trump doesn’t win.
Viral image
stated on May 23, 2024 in a Facebook post:
“The Simpsons” predicted Sean Combs’ legal problems.
Instagram posts
stated on May 16, 2024 in an Instagram post:
“Sunflowers are turning away from the sun because that’s not the sun.”
Instagram posts
stated on May 22, 2024 in una publicación en Instagram:
“Revelan momentos exactos de la caída del helicóptero con el presidente de Iran abordo…”.
Social Media
stated on May 29, 2024 in social media posts:
Judge Juan Merchan told New York jurors the verdict in Donald Trump’s trial does not need to be unanimous.
Instagram posts
stated on May 27, 2024 in an Instagram post:
When Secretary of State Antony Blinken was in Ukraine recently "he announced that they were going to suspend elections in Ukraine."
Facebook posts
stated on May 20, 2024 in a video:
Footage “shows a completely flat horizon proving the flat Earth and completely destroying the globe theory.”
X posts
stated on May 27, 2024 in a post:
“(Actress) Candice King calls out Rafah massacre and beheaded babies.”
Facebook posts
stated on May 26, 2024 in una publicación en Facebook:
Video muestra a Rita Moreno revelando “sus gotitas” que la hicieron “ex diabetica”.
Load more